Ongoing work on Pune's Riverfront Development sparks both civic excitement and environmental concerns.
By Prashant for PuneriPages.in
If you live in Pune like I do, you’ve probably heard debates about the Riverfront Development (RFD) project. Some people call it a game-changer, others fear it’s going to ruin the natural soul of our rivers. The recent High Court decision in favour of the PMC (Pune Municipal Corporation) gives us a moment to pause and understand what’s really happening—beyond the headlines.
Let me walk you through what I found while diving deep into this whole issue. I’ve tried to break it down the way I’d explain it to a friend over chai.
Table of Contents
What is Pune’s Riverfront Development Project?
Okay, so the PMC has been talking about this massive makeover of our rivers for a while now. The idea sounds impressive:
- Flood Protection: Build strong embankments to avoid flooding during heavy rains.
- Public Access: Imagine clean, walkable promenades, cycling paths, and green parks where right now there are overgrown banks and trash.
- River Cleaning: Stop untreated sewage from entering the river and improve water quality.
Sounds great, right? But wait — there’s another side to the story.
Engineering vs Ecology: The Real Tug-of-War
This is where it gets complicated. The people supporting the project believe it will modernize Pune and give us something similar to Sabarmati Riverfront in Ahmedabad. But environmentalists and activists are waving red flags.
- PMC’s Approach: Concrete embankments, beautification, and creating managed public spaces.
- Ecologists’ View: You’re treating a river like a canal. It’s a living ecosystem. Floodplains help absorb water naturally. Trees, birds, insects — all of that gets destroyed when you pour concrete everywhere.
This debate isn’t new. But it’s heating up again because of the recent court case.
What Was the Case About?
A group of concerned citizens filed a petition in the High Court challenging the 9-kilometre stretch of the RFD project. Their key points:
- Loss of Riparian Zone – The natural riverbank areas are getting destroyed.
- Floodplain Encroachment – Concrete walls speed up river flow and might cause worse flooding elsewhere.
- Tree Cutting – Mature riverside trees that are decades old are being cut.
So, What Did the Court Say?
The Bombay High Court junked the plea. But here’s the twist: they didn’t say the project is perfect. What saved the PMC was their formal promise to the court:
“We will take care of compensatory plantations and ensure ecological measures are in place.”
In legal terms, this undertaking is serious. It means if the PMC doesn’t follow through, they could be held in contempt.
But if you’re like me, you’re probably asking: “Can we really trust that promise?”
Can the PMC’s Promise Be Trusted?
Here’s where I started looking at past records. Turns out, this isn’t the first time PMC has promised tree plantations. And the results have been… mixed.
- Trees planted in past drives often didn’t survive more than a year.
- Maintenance and watering are not consistent.
- Tracking survival rates is difficult — and not always transparent.
So planting 100 saplings may sound good, but it’s not the same as losing a full-grown 50-year-old tree that was home to birds, squirrels, and insects.
Compensatory Plantation vs Natural Ecosystem
Let’s be real — planting new trees is not a bad thing. But equating that to the removal of thriving natural ecosystems is a false equivalence. It takes decades for a riverbank ecosystem to build itself. One JCB machine can tear it down in a day.
The PMC’s Promises (That We Should Track)
Here are the key things PMC told the court it would do. I’ve made a little tracker so we don’t forget:
| The Promise Made to the High Court | Responsible Body | Status | Last Verified |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maintain Compensatory Plantations for 9km Stretch | PMC | Pending | July 2025 |
| Appoint Expert Committee for Oversight | PMC | Pending | July 2025 |
| Ensure Debris is Not Dumped in River | PMC | Monitoring | July 2025 |
Let’s keep an eye on this, shall we?
FAQ – What Happens Next?
Q1: What happens now for this 9km stretch? Work is likely to speed up. Since the court didn’t stop it, construction will probably resume in full force.
Q2: Can the petitioners appeal to the Supreme Court? Yes, but we don’t know yet if they will.
Q3: Are there similar cases for other stretches? Likely. Activists are preparing petitions for other parts of the 44-km total project.
Q4: How can I, as a citizen, stay informed? Follow local news. More importantly, visit your stretch of the river. See what’s happening. Join local environmental groups. Ask questions. Share verified info.
Final Thoughts
This project is huge. It has the potential to transform how Pune connects with its rivers. But it also has the power to damage what little nature we have left in the city. We can’t blindly support or oppose it. We need transparency, accountability, and constant dialogue.
Let’s hope the promises made in court become actions on the ground.
And hey, if you see something happening near your stretch of the river—good or bad—drop me a message. Let’s keep each other informed.
— A concerned but hopeful Punekar.
About The Author
